Free tool · Revenue and pricing

Annual vs monthly subscription calculator

Compare expected revenue from one monthly subscriber with one upfront annual sale over the first 12 months, including churn and commission.

Build your scenario

Runs in your browser. No signup.

Starting values are editable examples.

Monthly: expected 12-month revenue
$390.69
Annual: upfront payout
$408.00
Annual − monthly difference
$17.31
Discount versus 12 monthly payments
20%

Assumes one cohort with a guaranteed first charge. Does not estimate annual renewal, refunds, failed payments, or time value of money.

Free, no sign-up. Your numbers stay in your browser.

Updated October 30, 2026

What the calculator compares

Almost every subscription app offers a monthly plan and a discounted annual plan. The question is which one earns more. This calculator compares what a monthly subscriber leaves, on average, over the first 12 months, accounting for those who cancel along the way, with what an annual subscriber pays up front.

The answer depends on three numbers: the monthly price, the annual price and how much monthly subscribers cancel. The store commission is deducted on both sides.

Why annual always looks better

The annual plan is discounted, so at first glance monthly earns more: 12 payments of $50 make $600, against $480 for annual. But a monthly subscriber can cancel at any time, and almost never pays all 12. Annual locks in the whole year on day one. The right math compares annual with what monthly really earns after cancellations.

How to calculate it

Monthly = price × expected paid months × (1 − commission) · Annual = annual price × (1 − commission)

  1. Estimate how many months, on average, a monthly subscriber pays in the first year, given monthly cancellation.
  2. Multiply by the monthly price and deduct the commission.
  3. Deduct the commission from the annual price.
  4. Compare the two amounts.

Worked example

The default values: a $50 monthly plan, a $480 annual plan, 5% monthly cancellation and 15% commission. With 5% cancellation, a monthly subscriber pays on average 9.19 of the 12 months. Monthly earns $390.69 and annual $408: annual comes out $17.31 ahead, even with a 20% discount.

PlanMathPayout over 12 months
Monthly$50 × 9.19 months × 85%$390.69
Annual$480 × 85%$408.00
Differenceannual − monthly$17.31

Expected paid months

The core of the math is how many months a monthly subscriber pays, on average, in the first year. With a monthly cancellation of c, they pay the first month for sure, the second with a 1 − c chance, the third with (1 − c)², and so on. Adding up the 12 months: 10.76 months with 2% cancellation, 9.19 with 5% and 7.18 with 10%.

Expected paid months = sum of (1 − cancellation)^m, from m = 0 to 11

Cancellation decides

With the same prices, the result flips with monthly cancellation. At 2% a month, almost everyone stays and monthly earns more. At 10%, annual wins comfortably:

Monthly cancellationMonthly over 12 monthsAnnualDifference
2%$457.48$408.00− $49.48
5%$390.69$408.00+ $17.31
10%$304.97$408.00+ $103.03

The tipping point

In this example, the flip happens between 4% and 5% monthly cancellation. At 4%, monthly still earns $411.50, slightly above annual’s $408; at 5%, annual pulls ahead. Knowing which range your app is in tells you whether it is worth pushing the annual plan on the paywall.

Calculate subscriber churn

Example with a $29.90 app

With the monthly plan at $29.90 and the annual at $199.90, a 44% discount on 12 monthly payments, the math swings toward monthly. With 5% cancellation and 15% commission, monthly earns $233.64 over 12 months and annual $169.92. The overly deep discount costs $63.72 per subscriber, unless it raises conversion a lot.

PlanMathPayout over 12 months
Monthly $29.90$29.90 × 9.19 months × 85%$233.64
Annual $199.90$199.90 × 85%$169.92

The per-month price on the paywall

Many apps show the annual plan as a monthly amount: $480 a year shows up as $40 a month, next to the $50 monthly plan. The comparison gets easier for whoever is deciding, and the discount is visible without any math.

The size of the discount

Too big a discount can flip the math. With the annual plan at $400, a 33% discount on 12 monthly payments, the payout drops to $340, below monthly’s $390.69 at 5% cancellation. Test the discount by looking at the result in dollars, not just annual plan conversion.

Cash: annual arrives first

Besides the total, annual brings the money in at once. That helps pay for acquisition: an annual subscriber who cost $150 to acquire pays back the cost on day one, while a monthly one takes a few months. For apps that grow with ads, that difference in timing can be worth more than the difference in value.

Calculate CAC payback

Refunds on annual plans

A refund on the annual plan returns the whole year. In the default example, if 5% of annual subscribers ask for a refund, annual’s average payout drops from $408 to $387.60, below monthly’s $390.69. A small refund rate can flip the result, so it pays to track refunds by plan type.

And in the second year?

The calculator only looks at the first 12 months. Over a two-year horizon, the annual renewal enters the math. As an assumption, if 60% of annual subscribers renew, annual earns $408 + 60% × $408 = $652.80 over two years. Monthly with 5% cancellation earns about $601.81 over 24 months. Replace the renewal rate with yours when you have the data.

Test it on the paywall

The best answer comes from a test: show paywall versions with the annual plan more or less highlighted, or with different discounts, and compare revenue per person who saw the paywall in each version.

Calculate paywall conversion

What the math leaves out

  • Annual renewal in the second year, which has its own rate.
  • Refunds, which weigh more on annual because they return the whole year.
  • Different conversion between plans: fewer people usually pick annual.
  • Failed payments on the monthly plan over the months.

How competitors present their plans

How the two plans are shown on the paywall changes which one people pick: which is highlighted, whether annual shows a per-month price, whether there is a trial. In Noctral’s library, you see the paywalls of apps that already make money, screen by screen.

See the onboarding and paywall library

How to use the calculator

  1. Enter the monthly and annual plan prices.
  2. Enter the measured monthly cancellation, or build scenarios if the app has not launched yet.
  3. Enter the store commission.
  4. Compare annual’s payout with monthly’s expected earnings and see the effective discount.

Which plan to highlight

This calculator tells you which plan earns more per subscriber. Deciding which to highlight on the paywall also depends on how many people pick each one. An annual plan that earns more per subscriber but that few people choose can bring less total revenue than a more popular monthly plan.

So use the result here together with real conversion: revenue per subscriber times the share of people who pick each plan. That sum shows which paywall leaves more money.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing annual with 12 full monthly payments, as if nobody cancelled.
  • Ignoring the commission, which weighs on both sides.
  • Offering an annual discount without checking it still earns more than monthly.
  • Measuring only revenue and forgetting that annual brings cash in first.

See it in real data

Mobile apps

Estimated revenue and downloads from the App Store and Google Play

See the feature

Frequently asked questions

How do I use the annual vs monthly subscription calculator?

Compare expected revenue from one monthly subscriber with one upfront annual sale over the first 12 months, including churn and commission.

Does an annual discount always increase revenue?

No. Compare the discount with expected churn, then validate actual conversion for both plans.

Should I offer a free trial on both plans?

It depends on the app. A trial increases how many start, but some cancel before the first charge. Measure trial-to-paid conversion for each plan before deciding.

Should I offer only the annual plan?

It depends on conversion. Many users will not pay for a year up front. Test both plans and compare revenue per person who saw the paywall, not just each plan’s value.

What monthly cancellation should I use before launch?

Use scenarios. Run the calculator with low, medium and high cancellation and see in which one annual starts to earn more. After launch, replace it with the measured number.

Do I need an account and are my inputs uploaded?

No account is required. Calculations run in your browser. Entered numbers and text are not included in tool analytics events; only the tool ID, language, and action are recorded.

Want to go past the numbers and see the real market?

Noctral shows the estimated revenue, the ads and the paywalls of apps that already earn, so you decide with market data and not just projections.

See Noctral data